Is going through Highway 120 faster than going down I-5, touching Mojave, then going up 395? That is what Google Maps suggests, but maybe it prefers interstates too much.
wrigleyd, I just tried Google maps, with
San Francisco to Lone Pine, and it gave me the Tioga route. ...maybe they are smart enough to cancel out Tioga when it is closed!
I got 7:07 hours via Tioga, and 7:19 via Bakersfield. Pretty close either way.
Edit after wrigleyd posted below: Now
that's weird!