Thank you Richard,
Both these boots do not look like insulated winter boots.
Were they adequate for winter conditions?
What was a better option - Hi-Tec Altitude or Adidas Terrex Conrax CP?
Does this mean that you do not believe that you need plastic boots for winter Mt.Whitney?
I have a recollection that I saw a yellow (plastic?) pair of boots on one of your photos.
Am I correct that they were worn by one of youyr partner?
The Adidas are waterproof (as far as that goes in slushy conditions) and insulated. As far as I know, the Hi-Tecs are not insulated.
For a day-climb, either boot works for me. In winter, you don't usually have to worry about much snowmelt on your boots. In Spring, it becomes a problem that can be solved by wearing plastics. I usually just put on a VBL sock and some wool to keep my feet somewhat comfortable. (Sounds completely backwards, but the only solution I know of for keeping your feet dry in Spring is plastic (or some waterproof double boot). The best any Gore-Tex boot has done for me is about 7 hours before snowmelt started leaking thru.)
I wouldn't do an overnight with either of these boots. Probably would use my Nuptse.
I just really like the Hi-Tec Altitude boots. I've been using them almost exclusively for about 5 years now. Climbed Whitney too many times and have done the Mexico Volcanoes with them the last 3 years.
You can't get the Adidas model anymore. The Terrex line is completely different now.
Yes, BP likes his plastics.